Misses,
waits & progress in naval missiles: Indo-Israeli LR-SAM trails this month
By Ajai
Shukla
Business Standard, 2nd Aug 13
The
aircraft carrier INS Vikramaditya, formerly the Admiral Gorshkov, which is
expected to join the Indian Navy later this year, is already late by 5 years
and its price has risen three-fold from $947 million in 2004 to $2.3 billion
today. It now emerges that for the next 3 years or so, INS Vikramaditya will
function without effective defences against anti-ship missiles --- a key threat
to warships today.
For this
the Russians are not to blame --- the Israelis are. The futuristic missile
defence system that was supposed to be fitted on the Vikramaditya, called the Long
Range Surface to Air Missile (LR-SAM), is also late by at least 3 years. The
LR-SAM is a missile, fired from a warship to shoot down an incoming anti-ship
missiles at ranges out to 70 kilometres. Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) is
developing the LR-SAM in partnership with the Defence R&D Organisation
(DRDO).
On
Thursday, Vice Chief of Naval Staff, Admiral RK Dhowan, said in New Delhi that
the Vikramaditya would arrive without a “close in weapons system” (CIWS,
pronounced sea-whiz), a ship-borne system to destroy incoming missiles and
aircraft. The navy will fit an AK-630 rapid-fire gun system on the Vikramaditya
when it arrives, but the more potent LR-SAM will only be fitted during the
aircraft carrier’s first refit. That would be at least three years down the
line.
Given these
continuing delays, the navy’s ageing INS Virat --- already half a century old
--- will continue in service till 2018. The INS Vikrant, the aircraft carrier
that is being built in Cochin Shipyard Ltd, is being launched on Aug 12, but
will only enter operational service by end-2018, says Dhowan.
The LR-SAM was
to be ready by 2011 for equipping three Indian destroyers that Mazagon Dock Ltd
is building in Mumbai under the so-called Project 15A. The LR-SAM delay has
held up Project 15A, with INS Kolkata, the first warship in this series, having
floating in the docks for the last seven years. INS Chennai and INS Kochi, the
other two destroyers in Project 15A are delayed too.
But there
is light at the end of this tunnel. Business Standard has learnt that a DRDO
team is heading for Israel for the first “hot test” of the LR-SAM this month.
This will check out all the missile systems --- detection, propulsion,
guidance, command and control --- functioning in tandem. While the radar, control
and navigation systems were tested last year, this will be the first test of
the entire system functioning together.
Says DRDO
chief, Dr Avinash Chander, “The crucial part of the test will be the missile’s
ability to perform manoeuvres. After this full-configuration test, we will
carry out trials next year from a ship.”
“There are
always uncertainties when one is developing a system of a technology class that
exists nowhere in the world.”
In exclusive
briefings at the DRDO’s missile cluster in Hyderabad, Business Standard was
told that the Israeli company is developing the front section of the LR-SAM,
including the seeker head that guides the missile, the front controller,
command electronics, and the explosive warhead that destroys the target.
The DRDO
has developed the rear section, including the two-pulse rocket motor, the rear
controller, the thrust vector control and the folded fins. DRDO scientists and
designers have also participated in the Israeli part of the development.
The LR-SAM is
made especially deadly by its two-pulse rocket motor. The first pulse propels
the missile towards the incoming target; while a ship-borne radar tracks the enemy
missile continuously, transmitting course corrections to the LR-SAM. When the
LR-SAM is near the target, its seeker locks onto the target, taking on the job
of guidance. Simultaneously, the rocket motor fires its second pulse, imparting
to the LR-SAM a high velocity that leaves the target with little time to
manoeuvre. The LR-SAM has both front and rear steering, which allows it to
manoeuvre sharply, remaining locked onto even a twisting and turning target.
Once tested
and proven, many LR-SAM components will be built in India. The DRDO says it has
developed suppliers within Indian industry, with two vendors developed for each
sub-system. For example, Godrej and SEC, a company in Hyderabad, will build the
two-pulse rocket motor.
A
ground-based version of the LR-SAM is simultaneously being developed for the
Indian Air Force (IAF), which is desperately short of air defence systems.
As long as the Aircraft Carrier rests in the carrier battle group, there is very little need for it having self defence capabilities.
ReplyDeleteAjai,Good Article but can you please tell that if BARAK-8 will not be ready for another 3 years as it is still under Testing Phase then how come Israeli Navy has started equipping its SAAR class missile boats with BARAK-8 Missiles system ?
ReplyDeleteHere is the Link :
http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2013/07/29/316128/israel-puts-barak-8-missiles-on-warships/
Never mind the Press TV Source , the same report came in "The Times of Israel " too...
Sparsh
Moral of the Story : Never, ever deal with the Russians.
ReplyDeleteRussia has cheated us on more than one occasion: be it spares for MiGs, no tech-transfer for T-90s, and swindling us on a second-hand Gorshkov.
Instead of investing any more billions on Russia, lets use the same money to spur our indigenous industry instead !
Why pay mother Russia, when Bharat Mata's kids can do the same job - and better ?
- - - - - - - - -
One also wonders why the Times of India, Hindustan Times and The Indian Express never publish such reports with the same frequency and malice that they report on DRDO's "delayed" projects.
You're probably the only journalist, who has the guts to take on the armed forces -- and hit where it hurts them the most.
Ajai Sahib, Any information on if the carrier battle groups ships are ready or are they still forming as well?
ReplyDeleteWell of my openion USA needs nuclear power CBG TO cross the antartic or pacific, we dont need to go or travel such long distances, different with subs az they are silent killers, I think we need more nuke propelled subs, possibly 10
ReplyDeleteI doubt that having dedicated LR SAM defense is necessary for an aircraft carrier, considering it will be a part of CBG with dedicated anti-air umbrella.
ReplyDeleteWhy even bother.
Ajai: would it be possible for you to find answers to a couple of questions:
ReplyDeletea) Is Barak-8 different from LRSAM? If so, how? Is the only difference that Barak-8 is 100% Israeli, while LRSAM has DRDO components? Or are there any performance differences?
b)The answer to the above might hopefully answer why Israel is already in the process of outfitting its missile boats with Barak-8, while LRSAM is still a couple of years away
Many thanks in advance
What Umbrella are we talking about here? The Same LRSAM, is going to be used by the other ships on escort, without it, their potency against carrier killer / disabler missiles is still questionable. Unless we have some other missile that is at par with the LRSAM for the missile defence role, in which case why even bother with the LRSAM.
ReplyDeleteI think india shold have bought russian air defence, how do chinese get rusdian tech, and we russian goods, russia would sell weapons to anyone, they do defence for business,
ReplyDeleteOur indian engineers and scientists are cool but our defence forces need to accept our stuff.
Arjun tank / 248 (2 versions)
Nag
Tejas 40 (mk1)
Artillery guns/ 150 pieces joke
Arjun is far better than T90, nag needs to be inducted and improved,
Stalin once said quality is qualitu but quantity has a quality of its own, 126 rafales could buy 350 tejas, but HAL SHOULD NOT take 30 years to delivet.
tdblog@yahoo.com:
ReplyDeleteNo country in the world is willing to sell India a aircraft carrier. SO the following:
1. Out of choice customers like India in the case of Air craft carriers have only to thank there stars that this one is finally coming to India,
2. With Russia China friendship growing to the next level, we are only thankful that Russia hasn't planned shelving the project and are still delivering the ship, even if it is mediocre than what was aimed for,
3. If we are so keen on missile defence system, pls spend money on it and buy it from Israel, they will deliver it far more quickly than the russians. Americans do not even have an interest in sharing such arms to India.
Biased again...your statement already late by 5 years and 3 more to go for missile defence system, is only there cause it is a Russian delivery...had it been US delivery...same would have been decorated like a 5 star general and published on your blog.
Nothing wrong in being US friendly, but not at the cost of our Country's national security. Russia offers far more technological depth than US in any product...US is not even interested in co developing a single product.
Rest I leave on your prudence on how you would like to highlight your views.
B'rgds,
tdblog@yahoo.com
I doubt that having dedicated LR SAM defense is necessary for an aircraft carrier, considering it will be a part of CBG with dedicated anti-air umbrella.
ReplyDeleteGold für WOW
Gold für World of Warcraft
CVBG will have sufficient air cover. May perhaps install the Barak-1 / AK-630 or the Kashtan CIWS system in the interim. IIRC there were 8 Kashtans in the original setup.
ReplyDelete